side bar
logo
Saturday, June 24, 2017

Columns

Book banning is unintelligible


The subject of book censorship comes to a boiling point during Banned Books Week, an annual event held from Sept. 25 to Oct. 2 that champions the freedom to read, the importance of the First Amendment and intellectual freedom.

It exposes actual or attempted bannings of books across the US, and stresses the importance of ensuring the availability of unorthodox or unpopular viewpoints for all who wish to read and access them. This is just one of the first steps we need to take to permanently put an end to unnecessary and biased censorship.

Book banning is rarely done on the basis of logic or thoughtful consideration, but more so on ignorance and prejudice. When books are banned for absurd reasons such as pro-communism in George Orwell’s “1984” or pro-racism in Harper Lee’s “To Kill a Mockingbird,” — the exact opposite of what these books advocate — you’re left wondering if some people have even read the books they challenge.

It seems that question is answered by The Texas Board of Education when they banned the children’s picture book “Brown Bear, Brown Bear, What Do You See?” by Bill Martin, a book that helps toddlers learn about colors and associate meaning to them.

The reasoning behind this was that they confused the author with another Bill Martin, author of “Ethical Marxism: The Categorical Imperative of Liberation” despite the fact that a simple glance at the book would have prevented this. In another display of prejudice, the same board voted to pass a resolution condemning textbooks they perceived as having a pro-Islam, anti-Christian slant.

Book banning does not protect children; it harms them, chiefly by attempting to instill political correctness or agendas and ignoring a novel’s core meaning and values. When books are banned and kept out of the grasp of children, you effectively limit their potential understanding of the world through other viewpoints.

This isn’t to say that common sense should not be a deciding factor as to what books are kept from the eyes of children in the school system.

If we truly care about the well-being and minds of our children, we must be sure to provide, not deprive, to encourage and not deter.

We must pursue a route in which the right to freedom of thought is expanded in our schools, and eradicate ignorance and prejudice from the discussion of our books. If we don’t, it will not just be our children that suffer, but our country, and the diversity of ideas we should cherish.

Marcus Smith is a creative writing freshman and may be reached at [email protected]


  • Arafat

    As I understand the school board's decision it was an attempt to introduce books that more accurately portray ed history. History, as you no doubt know, is not a science, is subject to interpretation AND prejudice. If the school board is attempting to find books that present a more accurate picture of history than kudos to them.

    The following article, for instance, addresses the widespread misunderstanding of the hisotry of The Crusades. The facts support this article's conclusions, yet you won't find a history book that presents these facts.
    http://www.americanthinker.com/2005/11/the_truth_

  • MPS

    I think your misunderstanding what's being stated in this article Arafat. While I understand your position, the resolution was passed not to present a more accurate depiction of history but put the textbooks in an anti Islamic pro Christian slant, while the Anti Islamic slant didn't exist. In addition to what was mentioned in this article, the primary basis of the resolution was to limit what was printed about Islam in our History books.

    That in no way helps present a more accurate picture, and this act was done out of but prejudice from a board of social conservatives trying to politicize textbooks. This only adds to the widespread misunderstanding you yourself has condemned.

  • Ryan

    I think it is ignorant to ban books even if the veiws are wrong or if we simply disagree. Books are important. Everyperson should use a filter when reading a book any book. My dad is a pastor and we were old enough to discern for ourselves he made us read the Koran, the Manifesto, and many others to learn about other beliefs and cultures…Rmember just because you dont believe it doesn't make it go away.

  • I strictly recommend not to hold off until you get enough money to order all you need! You can take the business loans or just sba loan and feel yourself free

Back to Top ↑
  • Sign up for our Email Edition

  • Polls

    Does the construction along Spur 5, which will eventually impact the U.S. 59 north and south on-ramps from I-45, affect your commute to class?

    • Yes, my commute will be dramatically different and much longer (36%, 38 Votes)
    • My commute will be slightly impacted, but it's not too much of a nuisance (29%, 31 Votes)
    • I don't commute/ I never use I-45 or Spur 5 (23%, 24 Votes)
    • I commute but had no idea about the construction (12%, 13 Votes)

    Total Voters: 106

    Loading ... Loading ...
  • Recent articles

  • Special Sections